Chapter recap
Legal Concept: Tort Law
Torts: civil wrongs outside a contract
✦
Tort = a civil wrong apart from contract, remedied with money damages.
✦
Three kinds: intentional, negligence, absolute/strict liability (Casualty outline adds vicarious liability).
✦
Civ. Code §1714(a): liable for willful acts and for a want of ordinary care or skill.
Intentional torts: libel, slander, false arrest, battery
✦
Intentional tort = a deliberate act, not a failure of care.
✦
Libel = written/fixed (Civ. §45); slander = spoken (Civ. §46).
✦
Other examples: false arrest, battery.
The four elements of negligence
✦
Negligence = duty, breach, proximate cause, damages.
✦
Intent is NOT an element of negligence.
✦
No actual harm = no damages = no negligence claim.
Proximate cause and efficient proximate cause
✦
Proximate cause = starts a natural, unbroken chain to the loss.
✦
Efficient proximate cause (CA) = the predominant cause; covered only if it is a covered peril.
✦
Not simply the first or last event in time.
Gross negligence and vicarious liability
✦
Gross negligence (CACI 425) = lack of any care or an extreme departure from reasonable conduct.
✦
Vicarious liability = answerable for another's wrong because of the relationship (Civ. §2338).
✦
Vicarious ≠ absolute: the agent's negligence must still be shown.
Absolute and strict liability
✦
Absolute/strict liability: no need to prove negligence.
✦
Work injury = absolute (Lab. §3600(a)); dog bite = strict (Civ. §3342(a)); blasting = ultrahazardous.
✦
Dog bite: liable even if the dog was never vicious before.
Damages: compensatory (special and general) and punitive
✦
Special = measurable out-of-pocket (medical, lost wages, repairs); general = pain and suffering.
✦
Compensatory = special + general.
✦
Punitive (Civ. §3294): punish; oppression, fraud or malice by clear and convincing evidence.
Defenses to negligence: comparative vs. contributory negligence
✦
California = PURE comparative negligence (Li v. Yellow Cab, 1975).
✦
Comparative: damages × (100% − plaintiff's fault %).
✦
Contributory: any plaintiff fault = $0.
✦
"I didn't mean it" is not a defense to negligence.
Assumption of the risk
✦
Voluntarily joining an activity with inherent risks = assuming those risks.
✦
Sports coparticipant: liable only for intentional injury or conduct outside the sport's ordinary range.
✦
Assumption of the risk can defeat even a strict liability claim (kennel worker, Priebe v. Nelson).