Chapter recap
Commercial Casualty Insurance
Occurrence vs. claims-made triggers
✦
Occurrence = when the injury happened; claims-made = when the claim is first made.
✦
An occurrence policy answers claims made years later.
✦
Claims-made is used for long-tail exposures that are hard to price.
Retroactive date and prior acts coverage
✦
Injury before the retroactive date = no coverage, even on a timely claim.
✦
ISO CGL retro date tests the injury date; many professional forms test the act date.
✦
No retroactive date = prior acts coverage.
Tails: Basic and Supplemental Extended Reporting Periods
✦
A tail extends the time to make claims, not the policy period.
✦
BERP: automatic, free; mini-tail 60 days, midi-tail 5 years.
✦
SERP: ask in writing within 60 days, up to 200% premium, unlimited, fresh aggregate.
What “general liability” covers and leaves out
✦
General liability = liability to others from premises, operations, products, completed work.
✦
Owned autos → commercial auto; own employees → workers' comp.
✦
Own property is first-party, never CGL.
CGL limits of insurance
✦
Products-completed operations has its own aggregate, outside the General Aggregate.
✦
Each Occurrence caps A + C for one occurrence.
✦
Defense is outside the limits in a CGL.
The three CGL insuring agreements: Coverages A, B and C
✦
A = BI/PD from an occurrence; trigger is injury during the policy period.
✦
B = listed offenses; trigger is the date of the offense.
✦
C = medical bills, no fault, incurred and reported within 1 year.
CGL definitions: occurrence, bodily injury, property damage, personal and advertising injury
✦
Occurrence includes repeated exposure; it need not be sudden.
✦
Property damage includes loss of use of property not physically injured.
✦
P&AI = 7 listed offenses; patent infringement is not one.
CGL definitions: completed operations, insured contract, territory, autos and mobile equipment
✦
Products-completed ops = away from your premises; not goods you still hold or unfinished work.
✦
Insured contract = assumed tort liability; the contractual exclusion does not apply.
✦
Forklift off the road = mobile equipment (CGL); cherry picker truck = auto.
CGL definitions: employees, leased and temporary workers, contractors
✦
Employee includes leased workers but not temporary workers.
✦
Temporary = fills in for leave or seasonal/short-term workload.
✦
CA ABC test (Lab. Code §2775): presumed employee unless all three conditions are proven.
CGL exclusions: intended injury, liquor, workers' comp, employment practices
✦
Intended injury excluded, except reasonable force to protect people or property.
✦
Liquor exclusion hits only insureds in the alcohol business.
✦
Employee injuries → workers' comp; employment practices → EPLI.
CGL exclusions: pollution; aircraft, auto and watercraft
✦
Pollution exclusion exception: smoke or heat from a hostile fire.
✦
MacKinnon (CA): exclusion does not plainly bar ordinary negligence with chemicals like pesticides.
✦
Non-owned watercraft under 26 feet, not for hire, stays covered.
CGL exclusions: care, custody or control; product recall
✦
Customer goods in your care, custody or control → bailee or inland marine, not CGL.
✦
Recall costs are excluded no matter who orders the recall.
✦
Product recall coverage is sold separately.
CGL exclusions: terrorism and microbial matter
✦
TRIA certified act: Treasury Secretary certifies; losses must exceed $5,000,000.
✦
Coverage must be offered; after rejection an exclusion may be used if state law allows.
✦
Fungi/bacteria exclusion: buildings yes, food and drink no.
Professional liability: why the CGL is not enough
✦
Pure financial loss is not BI, PD or P&AI, so the CGL never responds.
✦
Professional services exclusions remove even BI/PD from a design error.
✦
Malpractice for medical professionals; E&O for other advisers.
Professional liability triggers: claims-made, claims-made and reported, occurrence
✦
Professional liability: claims-made is the norm; occurrence is exceedingly rare.
✦
Claims-made and reported: claim made AND reported within the period or window.
✦
CA §11580.01: claims-made notice at the application heading and on the policy face page.
Defense provisions: professional liability vs. CGL
✦
CGL: defense outside the limit. Professional: defense commonly erodes the limit.
✦
Professional forms often require the insured's consent to settle.
✦
CA Civ. Code §2860: reservation on an issue defense counsel can control may require independent counsel.
Professional liability: exposure, perils, insureds and exclusions
✦
CA Civ. Code §2338: the firm answers for its agents' negligence in its business.
✦
Insureds: the firm, plus partners and employees acting for it; not the client.
✦
Excluded: dishonest or criminal acts; §533.5(a) bars covering criminal fines.
Employment practices and fiduciary liability
✦
EPL fills the gap: employment decisions cause economic harm and CGL excludes them.
✦
ERISA: a breaching fiduciary is personally liable; plan exculpation clauses are void.
✦
ERISA bond = fraud or dishonesty; fiduciary insurance = breach of duty.
D&O liability: exposures and who is insured
✦
Derivative suit = shareholder sues in the corporation's right (Corp. Code §800).
✦
CA §5239: insured volunteer nonprofit directors have no personal liability for ordinary negligence.
✦
Insured persons: past and present directors and officers, not outside auditors.
D&O insuring agreements and exclusions
✦
Side A pays individuals; Side B reimburses the company; Side C covers the entity.
✦
CA §317(i): insurance allowed even where indemnification is not.
✦
Insured v. insured bars collusive suits; final adjudication keeps defense until judgment.
The management liability suite: K&R and cyber
✦
Suite = D&O, EPL, E&O, fiduciary, K&R, cyber; not premises bodily injury.
✦
K&R pays ransom, ransom lost in transit and crisis consultants.
✦
CA Civ. Code §1798.82: notify residents within 30 calendar days of a breach.
EPLI: who is covered, exclusions, and what counts as a claim
✦
Standard EPLI covers employees, former employees and applicants; third parties need an endorsement.
✦
Common exclusions: workers' comp, ERISA benefits, FLSA wage-and-hour.
✦
A claim includes a written demand for non-monetary relief and an EEOC charge.
EPLI: damages, wrongful acts, bodily injury carve-out, intentional acts
✦
EPL damages include punitive and liquidated damages up to the limit, where insurable.
✦
Under CA law, punitive damages for one's own malice are not insurable (PPG).
✦
FEHA harassment rules reach employers with one or more employees.
✦
BI exclusion carves out emotional distress and humiliation; no intentional-acts exclusion, but §533 applies.
Commercial auto forms and the garage policy
✦
Garage = auto businesses; motor carrier = hauling property; BAP = ordinary businesses.
✦
CA §11580.9(a): business driver → garage policy primary; customer driver → garage policy excess.
✦
One garage form reduces gaps between CGL and auto; customers' cars need garagekeepers.
Garagekeepers: legal liability vs. direct coverage
✦
Legal liability: pays only if the garage is legally liable.
✦
Direct excess: no fault needed, but pays after the customer's own insurance.
✦
Direct primary: no fault needed and pays first.
BAP coverage needs: owned, hired, non-owned and uninsured motorist
✦
CA §11580.9(d): the owned-auto policy is primary; coverage follows the vehicle's policy.
✦
Hired = leased, rented or borrowed; non-owned = employees' own cars used for the business.
✦
UM can be deleted in writing; need not exceed $30,000/$60,000; UIM = limit minus amount paid.
BAP covered auto symbols
✦
2 = all owned; 3 = owned private passenger; 4 = owned other than private passenger.
✦
8 = hired (not from employees); 9 = non-owned (includes employees' cars used for business).
✦
Symbol 7 new autos: all owned autos covered or a replacement, plus notice within 30 days.
BAP: who is insured and key exclusions
✦
CA §11580.1(b)(4): permissive users must be covered; auto-business workers may be excluded.
✦
Exclusion → alternative: employees → WC/EL; completed work → CGL; cargo → motor truck cargo.
✦
Own fuel leaking from the tank is not excluded pollution.
✦
Fellow employee: Lab. Code §3601 allows suits for intoxication or aggression; the BAP excludes them unless endorsed.
BAP physical damage and two individual endorsements
✦
Comprehensive = any cause except collision or overturn; hitting an animal counts.
✦
Specified causes = named perils; the auto's own collision is not one.
✦
Individual Named Insured = person as named insured; Drive Other Car = named people driving autos they do not own.
Motor carriers and truckers
✦
CA §11580.9(h): trucker = transports property by auto for hire.
✦
Motor Carrier Act of 1980 = deregulation plus financial responsibility; federal minimum at least $750,000.
✦
Motor carrier form handles leased units, owner-operators and leases between carriers.
Commercial umbrella and excess liability
✦
Umbrella can be broader and drop down; follow-form excess only adds limits.
✦
Keep required underlying limits; the umbrella will not fill a gap the insured created.
✦
SIR applies only when the umbrella covers a claim no underlying policy covers.
Workers' compensation: the bargain and exclusive remedy
✦
Lab. Code §3600(a): compensation without regard to negligence, in place of other liability.
✦
Suits against the employer: willful assault, fraudulent concealment, certain defective products.
✦
Coworker suits only for intoxication or unprovoked aggression; the employer is not liable for them.
Misclassified workers and the ABC test
✦
Misclassified workers may never be insured or reported on payroll.
✦
ABC test (Lab. Code §2775): hiring entity must prove A, B and C; failing one = employee.
✦
Uninsured employer: may be sued; negligence presumed; no assumption-of-risk defense (§§3706, 3708).
When coverage is required and how to secure it
✦
Every employer except the state must secure compensation; no minimum headcount.
✦
Methods: authorized insurer, or a state self-insurance certificate (individual or group).
✦
A cash reserve without a certificate is not self-insurance.
The State Compensation Insurance Fund (SCIF)
✦
SCIF: fairly competitive and neither more nor less than self-supporting (Ins. Code §11775).
✦
§11784(c): may decline only for failed safety rules or risks beyond safe carrying.
✦
Producers use SCIF as a market for employers private insurers decline.
Medical and temporary disability benefits
✦
Medical care: no overall dollar or time limit (Lab. Code §4600).
✦
24 visits each for chiropractic, occupational therapy and physical therapy, unless authorized in writing or postsurgical.
✦
3-day wait, paid back if over 14 days or hospitalized; TTD = 2/3 of weekly earnings.
Retraining voucher, death and burial benefits
✦
Retraining voucher: up to $6,000; only $500 without documentation; cannot be settled.
✦
Death benefit: $320,000 (3+), $290,000 (2), $250,000 (1 total dependent).
✦
Burial: up to $10,000, in addition to the death benefit.
Workers' compensation fraud
✦
Claim fraud (Ins. Code §1871.4): fine up to $150,000 or double the fraud, plus restitution.
✦
Premium fraud (§11760; §11880 for SCIF): fine up to $50,000 or double the fraud.
✦
Misclassifying workers or understating payroll to cut premium is a crime even with no injury.
Employers liability, other states, voluntary comp and 24-hour coverage
✦
Employers liability (Ins. Code §11750.1(f)) answers employee suits outside compensation benefits.
✦
Other states = liability under another state's law; voluntary comp = scheduled benefits for workers not required to be covered.
✦
24-hour coverage (§1749.02) = WC plus nonoccupational coverage; never life insurance.
Experience rating and federal compensation programs
✦
Classification reflects hazard; experience mod compares losses to peers and adjusts future premium (§11730).
✦
State WC policies exclude workers under federal compensation laws.
✦
DBA = overseas government contracts; Longshore = docks and ship repair; Jones Act = seamen's right to sue.